Overhaul of an R1155
|
|
A few days ago (actually in
November 2021) this example of an R1155 arrived for some work.
It seems removal of cobwebs after a very long period of dormancy
had disturbed something vital. From the outside this old
receiver looks typical of a surplus wartime set that has been
worked on by a radio ham and in fact silent key G3PNV was responsible. |
 |
|
The first thing an R1155
devotee will notice is the strange tuning knob as well as more
common additions such as an S-Meter, mains socket etc, but a
view of the inside reveals more changes much less common. I can
see eleven valves including an EF50 and a couple of B7G based
valves as well as what looks like a full wave rectifier. Clearly
a basic R1155 circuit diagram will be of limited use as proper
examples use only octal valves. Also visible (and wired up) are
the original can-based condensers. That socket adjacent to the
aerial socket looks a bit odd and after some later investigation
I think its for a converter, either for say the 10/15m bands
or for 2m. My R206 was pressed into service with a nuvistor converter
for the 2m band about the same time G3PNV was using this receiver. |
 |
 |
|
The first thing to tackle
is the dial. Degradation of the perspex cover is completely obscuring
the dial markings and it's essential that this needs to be removed
and cleaned. Normally this is a straightforward job but in this
example the task is very puzzling. I've shown below the mechanism
revealed after prising off the replacement slow motion drive.
The drive is a version of a Muirhead type common in lots of WW2
equipments but in this instance it's difficult to see exactly
how it was fitted to the R1155. Below is shown the pointer which
is covered by the steel ring marked 10A/12684. The brass fitting
is home-made and is clamped to the end of the tuning condenser
shaft which has been cut short by an inch or so. Below the brass
part is a piece of fibre material used to clamp in place the
Muirhead mechanism. The clamp is secured to the chassis by a
long 8BA screw. The only way to remove the Muirhead mechanism
was by prising it off as its fixing screw is inaccessible. Of
course refitting it after cleaning everything will be a puzzle. |
 |
|
Above you can see the
dial markings have been modified by erasing two sets of numbers
corresponding to two wavebands. The range 75-200KHz is painted
over as are markings for Range 3. Without getting the set to
work I can't say whether these wavebands have been fitted with
alternative coils or just disabled in some way. I'll refer to
the wavebands 1 to 5 with 1 the highest SW band and 5 the VLF
band. |
 |
Now that the perspex is cleaned
up the dial is legible but I need to re-fix the slow motion drive
(below). The pointer is secured to a brass bush clamped to the
truncated tuning condenser shaft by a concealed screw. This is
almost completely inaccessible but has to be tight and with the
brass bush positioned to allow free movement of the pointer from
its exact start and end positions. It seems the pointer has to
be fixed securely before the panel is fitted or a hole drilled
in the chassis....
Below is a description of the
Muirhead Drive with tips on dismantling and reassembly.
|
 |
|
Above, upper right, you
can see the fibre material part that's screwed to the chassis
for clamping the mechanism. The reverse is shown on the right.
The problem is how to fix the assembly to the brass drive shaft
protruding from the pointer. The fixing screw for the pointer
bush and the fixing screw for the drive are sunken below the
front panel. How this was achieved by the late G3PNV must remain
a mystery. A specially angled screwdriver might be OK for the
pointer bush but other than trial and error to set the screw
that secures the drive to the brass pointer bush then jamming
it into place or perhaps bending the whole mechanism away from
the chassis and using a very thin screwdriver the only way I
can see to do it is by drilling holes through the lower edge
of the front panel and then the chassis. Maybe I could drill
the black plastic part of the dial as I'm fairly sure some of
these Muirhead drives have a screw access hole? This one doesn't...
Those two pointer knobs are
from two extra pots labelled RF Osc and RF gain. Both of these
pots needed to be detached to allow the panel to be removed. |
 |
|
 |
I think I managed to fit
the drive back together OK? One reason it proved difficult was
the square brass part to which the knob attaches was stuck in
place with dried lubricant and I hadn't realised it just pulled
off. The centre disks were also gummed together unlike the top
couple which have their disks riveted together.
See below...In order to fit
the parts you need to simultaneously engage the three disk pairs
with the brass centre part (E,F,G,H) and locate the bearing holes
top and bottom (A,B,C,D) for the outer disk pairs. To do this
you need to keep the upper ring slackly in place (nuts I plus
three others)to allow some jiggling. Screws J,K,L need to be
fairly slack to allow the disk pairs to be slightly separated
so that the two upper disks can be engaged. You'll notice that
one upper disk is fairly easy to locate but the other isn't.
The way around this is to open the lower disk pair using a plastic
rod with a flattened end. If this is jammed in place the second
upper disk can be engaged with the centre spindle followed by
the lower disk pair. The final part of the assembly is to very
carefully locate the lower bearing of the second upper disk.
Once all the parts are located correctly tighten the four nuts
holding the upper ring then tighten screws J,K,L (note there
are three screws located 120 degrees apart L is hidden behind
the centre spindle). |
|
 |
 |
 |
Above you can see the
Muirhead drive is now put back and seems to be nice and smooth
in operation.The most difficult part of the job was refitting
the pointer because the securing screw was inaccessible. I drilled
several holes in the lower edge of the panel (out of sight) and
the chassis and was able to engage the securing screw after grinding
a screwdriver to perfectly fit the screw used to tighten the
bush.
I found by trial and error I
was able to fit the home-brew drive securing block so it matched
the screwhole in the panel and gave enough clearance to get to
the grubscrew in the Muirhead drive. Because the clearance between
the rear of the drive and the R1155 panel was only a couple of
mm I had to grind a second screwdriver to fit.
Left; compare with the picture
above... after cleaning the plate you can see the original ranges.
It seems from dial mods 1500/600KHz has been replaced as has
200/75KHz. |
|
|
I guess nobody will ever
undertake this conversion but it's interesting to record it.
The accuracy of the drawing isn't perfect but it gives you the
general idea.
One drawback with this is what
would happen if excessive force is used once an endstop is reached?
If the pointer shifts inadvertently
there's a pointer access problem, hence the trouble taken to
drill the screwdriver access holes so the quarter inch adaptor
could be really secure. I did wonder whether a new method could
be used by drilling a hole from the front of the adaptor into
the tuning condenser shaft, tapping the latter and putting a
star washer into the gap before tightening a screw to hold them
together.
Commercial tuning arrangements
usually design a safety feature to overcome misalignment or damage
from excess force which can result in a very complicated design. |
 |
|
|
While I was fitting the tuning
bits together I noticed not one but several components and wires
that had come adrift so getting this R1155 working might be more
tricky than I first imagined. Producing a rough circuit diagram
should be next on the agenda...
Looking at the valves used in
the receiver it looks like the original design must have been
changed with a new 6AK5 RF stage, original X66 mixer (possibly
using a 6SN7 local oscillator?). The extra valves lower right
of the picture above may even suggest
it's now a double superhet as the extra 6AG5 and EF50 don't seem
to go too well with the KTW62 and EF39 unless they're employed
as a second local oscillator and mixer? I looked on the Net for
likely modifications and there are many but I reckon none describe
exactly what's been done. I looked again at dangling wiring and
its possible that some instances may be design changes dating
back decades so maybe the best option is to power the receiver
from an external HT PSU which I can slowly increase to a working
level and if there's no smoke or anything untoward try reconnecting
the various floating components...
After a week or so of repairing
circuit boards in the day job I looked again at the R1155 and
decided it would be too time-consuming to trace circuit details
so instead decided on the option of attaching an external power
supply and attempt to diagnose any faults that are present. Lots
of the hanging wires looked like they may have been deliberately
disconnected so powering the receiver may be a worthwhile proposition.
I attached an HT supply between the rectifier cathode and chassis
(I had intended to look for an HT negative feed in the rat's
nest of wires but gave up, at least temporarily).
I wound up the HT whilst monitoring
the current and found the latter dropped slowly from around 25mA
at a low initial voltage and as the voltage increased to 200mA.
This rather high current dropped off fairly quickly and once
stable at a realistic low value I wound the HT to 250 volts with
no ill effects. Under the chassis is the audio output transformer
which has a 47 ohm resistor across its output tags and to these
I connected a loudspeaker. I then connected a 6.3 volt supply
to the valve heater circuit. The HT current slowly rose to 45mA
with an HT reading of 257 volts and with the wavechange switch
producing reassuring cracklings noises in the speaker as it was
turned.
I had a convenient long wire
to hand and looked for somewhere to connect it under the chassis.
At the RF input end of the wavechange yaxley switch I noticed
a detached rubber covered wire that appeared to have come off
a nearby tag and connected this to my long wire. I then turned
the RF gain and volume control fully clockwise which brought
up some hissing in the speaker and swung the tuning knob from
end to end in the different settings of the wavechange switch.
I was rewarded with a strong broadcast station (Radio 4) in Range
5 (75-200KHz) at a setting corresponding to a pointer reading
of 18MHz which is around what would have been about 190KHz on
the painted-out innner scale. No other signals were present so
I connected a signal generator to the same connection as the
long wire and found all the wavebands appeared to be working...
meaning the local oscillator is probably OK on all wavebands
(but read on). At some point I'd found the signals were heterodyning
and by trial and error found the upper switch at the left of
the front panel was responsible. This is an old RAF plastic switch
with its toggle broken off and is used to turn on the BFO.
All told the results are vaguely
promising. I found the aerial socket wasn't connected so that
needs sorting out but most of the various controls seem to work
including a pair of potentiometers adjacent to the S-Meter which
affect its sensitivity and zero-setting. Next I'll see if the
internal PSU works, fix the aerial circuit and see what each
waveband covers.
The old mains lead terminated
in a circular Belling Lee plug was a tatty cloth covered lead
with decaying rubber insulation and an ancient 13A plug so I
removed and refitted the Belling Lee plug to a new 13A lead,
plugged it into the R1155 and switched on. After 40 seconds the
speaker came to life, much louder than before no doubt because
the heater voltage was now a nominal 6.3V, and after resoldering
a detached coax lead to the Belling Lee aerial socket (which
had a broken inner so needs replacing) and attaching my long
wire with a croc clip stations were present on all but the highest
range. It looks like the lowest range is consistent with the
painted-out dial calibrations, the next correct and the third,
medium waves, but with reduced sensitivity. HT at the output
transformer measured 280V and presumably the original ground/bias
circuitry is now correct.
The lower switch at the bottom
left, I think may switch in a Q Multiplier as tuning across stations
(sometimes) gave a sharper and enhanced response. Overall sensitivity,
no doubt helped by the newer valves, is really good and I can
hear an unusual long wave broadcast which I think might be a
Polish broadcast at a very good strength a little lower than
the Irish station on 252KHz. I need to check the various wavebands
for alignment, for example to see why medium waves broadcasts
are weaker than normal and why the highest band is flat (of course
this latter may be due to poor H F conditions). The BFO switch
needs replacing as does the aerial socket. |
|
The next day I used the Tiny
SA to gauge the waveband coverages and found all worked but miles
out (see later) when it came to RF alignment. One end would be
very sensitive and the other over 30dB different in sensitivity.
The combination of a very long wire and decent AGC gave a misleading
effects. On the lowest frequency band marked at the wavechange
knob as 75-200KHz tuned 80 to 210KHz. The second range marked
200 to 500KHz tuned 200 to 530KHz. Next 600 to 1500KHz tuned
900 to 1600KHz. The first shortwave range tuned 3.5 to 7.7MHz
and the last tuned 7.7 to 19MHz.
The receiver IF is 560KHz and
I'm assuming this is unchanged. The local oscillator in the R1155
is greater than the signal frequency on all bands "quote
from RAF document AP1186". That means if you set a signal
generator to roughly the middle of Range 1 at 13MHz you will
hear a signal when the pointer is close to 13MHz and by tuning
the receiver to 14.12MHz you'll hear a second signal. If alignment
is good the second signal will be weaker in signal strength than
the first but, because the R1155 is very sensitive and has good
automatic volume control the two signals will probably sound
exactly the same. This can be quite confusing but can be resolved
by attenuating the output from the signal generator. In the original
design a magic eye shows signal strength but in this modified
example a complicated S-Meter has been added. This has a very
large gain requiring both a sensitivity cointrol and a zero adjust
knob. |
|
DIAL MARKING |
DIAL MARKING |
ACTUAL TUNING |
ACTUAL TUNING |
CORRECT OSC |
CORRECT OSC |
IMAGE |
IMAGE |
|
RANGE |
LOW |
HIGH |
LOW |
HIGH |
LOW |
HIGH |
LOW |
HIGH |
|
5 |
75KHz |
200KHz |
80KHz |
210KHz |
635KHz |
760KHz |
1195KHz |
1320KHz |
|
4 |
200KHz |
500KHz |
200KHz |
530KHz |
760KHz |
1060KHz |
1320KHz |
1620KHz |
|
3 |
600KHz |
1500KHz |
900KHz |
1600KHz |
1160KHz |
2060KHz |
1720KHz |
2620KHz |
|
2 |
3MHz |
7.5MHz |
3.5MHz |
7.7MHz |
3.56MHz |
8.06MHz |
4.12MHz |
8.62MHz |
|
1 |
7.5MHz |
18MHz |
7.7MHz |
19MHz |
8.62MHz |
18.56MHz |
9.18MHz |
19.12MHz |
|
|
I've marked up the table above
to indicate what's needed during alignment. The DIAL MARKING
columns reflect the figures at the wavechange switch, the ACTUAL
TUNING figures indicate the measured frequencies, CORRECT OSC
are the correct frequencies for the local oscillator based on
the marked frequency and IMAGE figures are false signals. Because
of the way the dial has been painted over only Range 5 (whose
numbers are still visible), and Ranges 4, 2 and 1 are clearly
OK but Range 3 has probably been tweaked to cover the top end
of the mediumwave broadcast band. I started to align the stages
and quickly found the trimmers seemed not to be logically positioned
so I checked a previous alignment I'd done a few years back and
(re)discovered the seemingly random trimmer layout (below) which
explained everything (R = Range number). |
 |
|
Alignment involves tweaking
coils as well as trimmers and this can be a tricky business with
the R1155 especially if this metal screen is missing as was the
case in my last R1155 commissioning job. If the set has been
previously worked on it's possible the coil dust cores have been
damaged or just stuck. Access is incredibly awkward but can be
helped by tackling the other ends of the coils with a suitable
tool.
HF end=trimmer adjustments
LF end=coil tweaking |
|
The view below is as seen
from the rear of the receiver and is the reverse of the view
of the trimmers above.
Range 1 coils for RF amplifier
are mounted on the chassis |
 |
|
|
|
During the testing I discovered
slight discrepancies and sure enough I should have checked the
IF response as it turned out to be 568KHz. At this point I should
mention that the old receiver didn't work most of the time. Something
was causing it to go completely deaf or more accurately something
was causing it to come alive for short periods. With lots of
difficulty using a monitor shortwave receiver to check the R1155
local oscillator I found out that Range 1 oscillator was wrongly
set to be below the tuned frequency and correctly above for Range
2.
It's unlikely the IF would have
been modified so my first step will be to correct this and realign
the IF amplifier to 560KHz. Associated with this is the BFO.
The R1155 designers chose to use the second harmonic of a 280KHz
oscillator which could be mighty confusing to a restorer.
Fortunately (two and a half
sets of three of) the IF cores were tweakable and I tuned them
so the response is now 560KHz then I looked at the RF alignment.
The two HF ranges cannot be aligned without freeing the coil
dust cores. I can tune the local oscillator so that it roughly
matches the dial markings but as the receiver is tuned LF the
response drops off quite rapidly. In fact to set the second RF
amplifier coils on Range 1 for 18MHz I had to add 50pF across
its trimmer. This is quite a lot so I'd guess the coil dust cores
are too far away from optimum. I noticed many cores have damaged
slots so it'll be difficult or impossible to align them. |
|
As a break from struggling with
alignment I decided to replace the broken BFO switch and, as
I had a spare one matching it, I used this as it fits the larger
than average hole in the panel. This is an Air Ministry switch
type 10F-10338 and has a pair of contacts for both make and break. I
fitted the new switch then found no trace of the BFO. |
|
I noticed this very clean
example of an R1155B on Ebay the other day. Clearly that replacement
Muirhead dial wasn't as unusual as I'd imagined. Also note the
S-Meter with that adjacent adjusting control. This one, mounted
upside down, suggests a simpler drive circuit because that on
the one I'm looking at provides more current the stronger the
signal. |
 |
|
|
It's been a few months since
I looked at this R1155 (in fact January 2022 and it's 1st August
2022 tomorrow!!). A mixture of being too busy with the day job
and other activities plus being too chilly over the Winter in
my workshop delayed progress. Anyway work had been suspended
because a component fault had suddenly stopped progress. My eyesight
isn't wonderful these days but armed with magnifying goggles
and a strong torch I tackled the recalcitrant R1155. As usually
happens when WW2 equipments are worked on various components
can suddenly fail and sudden cessation of sound from the temporary
loudspeaker had ground work to a halt in January. I plugged in
a pair of headphones yesterday and plugged in the mains lead
only to quickly whip them off with my ears ringing from the racket
which had slowly increased to a crescendo as the valves warmed
up.
This R1155 has been very extensively
modified and lots of the "new" circuitry has clearly
been constructed by trial and error with resistors and condensers
daisy-chained and hanging in mid air and with countless "loose"
wires in evidence. In fact it was a miracle I'd got as far as
I had in its overhaul to-date. Although the back end of the set
is (sort of) working the front end is as deaf as a post so with
my goggles and torch and a trusty multi-meter I checked the obvious..
a tiny 6AK5 which seems to connect with a coax lead to the aerial
socket (just replaced). Hanging in the breeze is a 470K resistor
and a pair of siver mica condensers,, these couple the aerial
to the 6AK5 control grid the coil pack and the AVC circuitry.
A resistor and condenser supply the screen grid which is sitting
at 49 volts but a yellow wire heading off to the the wavechange
switch connected to the 6AK5 anode is sitting at a mere 6 volts.
A short-circuit (actually 11 ohms) chassis mounted condenser
is the culprit and cutting off the lead allowed the anode to
rise to... 7 volts. I followed the wavechange switch contacts
(a torch and goggles being vital due to the horrible design of
the coil pack) and discovered a daisy chain of coil tags wired
to a 15Kohm resistor on a tag panel screwed to the end of the
metal enclosure. This measured not 15Kohm but a whopping 125Kohm
so I cut it off and fitted a new 12Kohm. This restored the 6AK5
to an operating state with the front panel RF gain now finally
doing its job (that's a 3Kohm pot in the 6AK5 cathode).
The following pair of pictures help show
the rogue parts. |
|
|
I switched on my HP8640B
and looked for a signal. I found the IF around 560KHz and a few
short wave signals but for some odd reason, varying the signal
strength resulted in either a cleanish output or motor-boating
which seemed to emanate in cause from the extensive mass of components
at the end of the chassis. As I pondered this, the signal to
which I was tuned just disappeared and a slight suggestion of
extra heat (a sort of faint burning smell) caught my attention.
A quick check revealed the HT line was only 2 volts and the rectifier
valve was red hot. Thankfully HT is NOT supplied by silicon diodes
and the rectifier valve was limiting current to a safe value..
transformer and choke-wise. I unplugged the sizzling rectifier,
unplugged the set and began a search for a zero ohm resistance
from HT to ground. Initially I imagined the smothing condenser
(blameless) then a couple of those chassis-mounted 0.1uF condensers
(also blameless), so donned my goggles and poked the torch into
the mess of wiring and looked for a potential culprit but drew
a blank so I connected a low voltage power supply to the HT line
(to look for the origin of max smoke). The best I could do was
1.2 volts at 3 Amps but I found nothing heating up so decided
to disconnect HT from different parts of the circuit. Maybe the
4th disconnected wire or was it the 5th or 6th drew my attention
to a pair of Wearite cans mounted on a small chassis screwed
over the holes for the original first IF can. This rings a bell.
Ages ago a condenser had failed in a previous R1155 repair and
this had been INSIDE the IF can resulting in the failure of the
IF transformer primary winding. That would explain why a "new"
Wearite IF transformer was in place. A junk-box transformer had
done the job but not quite... Sticking out of the hole below
the transformer was a red plastic covered wire. I thought this
was part of unused circuitry but no.. the wire was pushed over
the core screw and was a method of adjusting coil tuning, with
a second piece of sleeving I hadn't noticed providing tuning
for the other coil. In fact the new Wearite IF transformer uses
twin cans with isolated primary and secondary coils (hence two
lower tuning adjustments at two different cans). |
|
|
Anyway an HT short
was present within this modification and I could see no option
other than to remove the small sub-chassis for investigation.
I removed 4 self-tapping screws, cut off a couple of coax leads
and a few wires and withdrew the thing. On the underside fitted
close to the metalwork were two Metalmite condensers (HT and
AVC). The HT decoupler measured zero ohms. Oddly the position
of this condenser isn't 100% essential as a nearby HT anchor
point can be decoupled instead, but back in the 1960s when the
condenser was almost new who'd have imagined it failing 60 years
later! After another spate of messing around the IF sub-chassis
was refitted and a quick check revealed an IF signal could (again)
be heard.... but that'll do for today as an urgent delivery has
just turned up for a very dead lift at Worthing Hospital. |
 |
|
Bad condensers. Left 11ohms,
right 0 ohms |
|
|
|
I discovered my HP8640B
was acting up with its RF output meter showing a low reading.
Hopefully its not going to be too serious a fault. Testing each
waverange of the R1155 using a long wire suggested not only was
the set a trifle deaf but I'm wondering if the stations I'm picking
up are the result of TRF reception. Radio 4 on 200KHz tunes really
broadly and each band seems to have an increasing background
noise level as the tuning goes from low to high. This would maybe
be the case if the RF tuning is poor, being set to resonate with
a working local oscillator? During the next 10 minutes I noticed
that just gently touching a silver mica condenser wired at the
end of the coil box resulted in crackling although its soldering
looks perfect... yet another puzzling clue to something. |
|
For want of nothing better
to do and having decided extra test equipment would prove unhelpful
at present (the wrong idea.. I was soon to discover) I looked
at the strange filament lamp seen in the chassis view above,
and right. A meter revealed it was very odd, open circuit and
with its leads sitting at 3.6 volts (but jumping around a little)
and ground. Maybe it's being used as a heater feed to balance
heater current as there are a few non-standard valves sitting
on the chassis (note the construction of the R1155 makes it really
difficult to trace wiring)? |
 |
 |
A search of the Internet
turned up this picture, so its not an open circuit filament lamp
but is a neon lamp something like a GE LM-46 which is similar
to the NE16 and RCA 991. |
|
|
In passing... most of
this R1155 wiring is original rubber covered stranded wire, but
not as bad as some examples because the rubber hasn't perished
unduly. Anyway, I decided to just unsolder the lamp and withdraw
it for a visual check and suddenly all became clear in several
ways. Firstly the intermittent crackling was explained, secondly
the deafness was explained and thirdly why general performance
was dreadful. The bulb is a neon, and although unmarked is likely
to strike at say 110 volts. The HT feed resistor marked 200 ohms
measures 1.4Mohm and the live rubber insulated connection is
partly (and forcibly) wrapped around the wavechange switch centre
spindle. At the points of contact the rubber has melted and the
conductor is touching the metal spindle. Almost certainly the
neon is used for stabilising the local oscillator, but whoever
fitted it passed its connecting wire too close to the the wavechange
switch spindle and after years of use the rubber wore through,
an HT short resulted, and the 200 ohm resistor got very hot and
expired. During testing, the wavechange switch would be rotated,
disturbing the shorting wire and allowing the local oscillator
to work for the brief period when the wire wasn't shorting the
HT feed via 1.4Mohm to ground. This high value would allow the
local oscillator to work intermittently but it would be marginal
to say the least!
All done.. I refitted the neon
lamp after determining it stabilised at about 125 volts. Assuming
it needs 2mA to run after striking and that the local oscillator
would draw about 3 to 4mA with the HT line at say 280 volts I
worked out that the load resistor would be between 31K and 25K.
A resistor of 27K failed to illuminate the neon with its output
registering about 82 volts so by trial and error I found a parallel
47K did the trick. This makes 17K giving the total current about
9mA. In fact the VR99 (if its an original=X66) sinks around 4.75mA
so the current through the load resistor will be this plus 4.25mA
for the neon. In fact the X66 is rated at 100 volts so will draw
a little more.
I noticed background noise was
up and plugging in my long wire proved the set was working correctly
for the first time. It had performed so well as a TRF receiver
I hadn't realised the mixer wasn't working. It explains why I'd
been having a problem trying to align the coilpack (see below)
and bearing in mind I'd tweaked all the trimmers as far as they'd
go. For example Range 3 failed to drop below 900KHz when the
dial had shown 600KHz. Clearly, operating as a TRF the coils
were resonating with a local oscillator of zero Hertz. At the
higher frequencies this did not have as much effect as can be
seen below where Range 1 was almost OK. |
|
DIAL MARKING |
DIAL MARKING |
ACTUAL TUNING |
ACTUAL TUNING |
|
RANGE |
LOW |
HIGH |
LOW |
HIGH |
|
5 |
75KHz |
200KHz |
80KHz |
210KHz |
|
4 |
200KHz |
500KHz |
200KHz |
530KHz |
|
3 |
600KHz |
1500KHz |
900KHz |
1600KHz |
|
2 |
3MHz |
7.5MHz |
3.5MHz |
7.7MHz |
|
1 |
7.5MHz |
18MHz |
7.7MHz |
19MHz |
|
|
A quick check with the mixer
working correctly I was able to tweak the trimmers to bring the
dial back into sync with the output from the signal generator. Now
I should puzzle over the fact that Range 2 dial numbers are painted
out and why Range 3 is entirely painted out and a new, and as
yet an un-numbered scale is inked in. Also what function has
the alien EF50.
I looked at the dial again in
conjunction with the socket fitted next to the S-Meter. In my
own 2 meter set-up in the 1960s I used my R206 tuning 24 to 26
MHz to cover the 2 Meter band. The drum dial of the R206 was
just the job to give me a decent spread of tuning. Below, I've
realised that Range 3 could carry markings for the 2 meter band,
for example with 144MHz next to "7.5" and 146MHz near
to "3.5". Possibly the Range 5 scale was initially
going to be used as these frequencies aren't popular but, as
this was physically quite narrow, Range 3 was then preferred.
Below, the spread occupies most of the dial suggesting Range
2 could have been the IF for the external converter making 144MHz
= 7.5MHz, 146= 5.5MHz and 148=3.5MHz. This can be achieved if
the converter used a local oscillator crystal tuned to 151.5MHz
which would precisely produce these figures.
An alternative is to use Range
3 (the MW range) for the converter IF but this would entail spreading
its coverage to at least 2MHz, say 1MHz to 3MHz, but the existing
coils would need to be changed, an almost impossible task without
a major stripdown. Clearly this wasn't done because Range 3 tuning
is still close to the markings at the wavechange knob. I prefer
the former idea and of course, as that would align with the 2
Meter band in the USA a US magazine such as QST might have been
the source of the converter design? |
 |
|
It's rather strange to
be following in the footsteps of G3PNV. Looking at his improvements
to the R1155 and having briefly noted the presence of several
unusual valves I'd estimated the changes might have been quite
significant, however this seems not to be the case. The use of
the Wearite IF transformer with the complication of fitting and
alignment seems to me to have been a junk box source, and now
after tracking down the reason for the loudspeaker not working,
I've discovered another unusual change. Bearing in mind the availability
of cheap audio output valves why on earth did G3PNV use an EF50
valve to drive his loudspeaker? Maybe it had some special characteristics
and the awkwardness of fitting a B9G holder might support this
but it's not something I might have done. Rather than his triode-connected
EF50 I'd have used a 6V6. Looking at another change I see a 6AG5
has replaced the usual VR100 IF amplifier. Like the EF50 this
is an odd choice of valve because the VR100 is variable-mu and
the 6AG5 a sharp cut off beam pentode good for up to 400MHz.
I suppose this means that the overall gain characteristics of
the set are completely different because the AVC has a different
effect on the IF amplifier, and to that matter the RF amplifier.
I guess my brief to restore the old receiver to its last working
state, and time of course, precludes any changes. |
|
Another bunch of duff
parts. The tubular condenser is from the 6AK5 AVC line, the Metalmite
was decoupling the mixer screen grid and the Hunts was the feed
from the LF amplifier anode putting +11 volts on the EF50 control
grid.
The burnt resistor is the ex-220
ohm (=1.4Mohm) neon lamp load.
I also removed a very decayed
rubber heater lead between the EF50 and 6AG5 that was intermittently
sparking to the EF50 anode/G2 pins.
The set is now relatively immune
to tapping whereas previously even a disapproving stare resulting
in crackling.
The dead speaker turned out
to be a bad connection at one of the EF50 pins. A replacement
valve didn't improve this so I may squeeze the valveholder contacts
together so they'll grip the pins better. |
 |
|
|
I decided to check the
tuning range of the various wavebands. I suspect Range 3 has
been tweaked in the past as I can get it to cover the medium
waveband from 1610 to around 700KHz. I say tweaked, but the original
oscillator core has been changed. This has a slot at the front
panel end but no slot visible from the rear. I don't think the
process was carried to the RF stages because these cores/trimmers
are tuning LF of the new range. Apart from this the other ranges
seem reasonable.
From the results an extra small
capacitor (similar to that of the scope probe) added to the oscillator
trimmer should restore original Range 3 coverage, however, as
the dial markings are erased this may be a retrograde step as
fuller coverage of the medium waveband is perhaps more desirable?
Using an oscilloscope for convenience
even though it was adding capacitance to the test points (=oscillator
trimmers), and pulling down the frequencies, the following table
gives the latest tuning ranges with the nominal figures in brackets.
The local oscillator is always HF of the tuning dial setting. |
|
RANGE |
OSC LOW END KHz |
TUNING KHz |
OSC HIGH END KHz |
TUNING KHz |
|
1 |
7800 |
7240 (7500) |
18500 |
17490 (18000) |
|
2 |
3450 |
2890 (3000) |
7600 |
7040 (7500) |
|
3 |
1267 |
707 (600) |
2100 |
1540 (1500) |
|
4 |
752 |
192 (200) |
990 |
430 (500) |
|
5 |
636 |
76 (75) |
750 |
190 (200) |
|
|
I was looking at the EF50
base and noticed there was a 5Kohm cathode resistor (measuring
5.38Kohm and dating from around 1932) for auto-bias. There's
no decoupling and any attempt to add any results in hugely excessive
gain accompanied by instability. This is such a strange circuit
and choice of valve I wonder if was proposed in some erudite
technical article in the late 50s/early 60s? That high value
resistor certainly prevents a leaky audio coupling condenser
from doing any damage.
Now that the receiver is working
tolerably well, apart from the dratted EF50 that keeps going
off, I decided to swap all the double/triple chassis mounted
condensers for new standard types. As I expected, although the
old ones are pretty dreadful (some with melted wire insulation)
not much change in receiver performance, possibly due to AVC
doing its job keeping the loudspeaker output sounding constant.
I also swapped some small 1960s types that looked in poor physical
condition. If this isn't done the old condensers are likely to
fail short-circuit progressively, and I noticed that as the old
condensers were swapped the HT voltage had risen around 20 volts
having been relieved of their leakage.
The BFO area seems to have lots
of disconnected wiring so may have been troublesome many years
ago? Two extra valves are fitted below the S-Meter. One is probably
driving the S-Meter and the other maybe used for audio detection
or AVC. Because of the mess of wiring and difficult access I
haven't worked this out yet. During todays activity I decided
to add a loudspeaker socket. Some wiring was present from the
audio output transformer and to this I added a phono socket into
which I can plug my HRO speaker which is fitted with a phono
plug. |
|
|
|
During the time I'd had
the R1155 on the bench I'd become more and more disatisfied with
the operation of the tuning dial. It wasn't too bad in slow but
when operated in direct mode it felt really stiff with a metal-to-metal
scraping feel to it. I tried the dial on an RF26 and it felt
really smooth in both modes so I decided to see what was wrong.
Previously I'd had to overhaul the dial and after refitting it
I'd assumed nothing could be done further, but I decided to find
out the problem and removed it with a lot of trouble. The way
its fitted requires a screw to be tightened to hold the output
collar to the tuning condenser and this screw is awkward to get
at. In a normal aplication there's no difficulty because the
designers know the screw must be accessible but using the dial
with the R1155 needs some mechanical prowess.
After pulling off the dial I
initially smeared lots of copper ease on the mechanism and it
soon freed up and operated smoothly in fast and slow. I was then
prepared to refit it but something wasn't right because the anchoring
flange seemed to need pressing in by several millimetres to align
it with the mating slot. At this point I'll explain a little
more. G3PNV had used a fibre block with a slot cut in it to mate
with the flange on the dial. Because the fibre block was mounted
about 10mm deeper than the end of the tuning condenser shaft
he'd made a small metal extension to extend the original flange.
This had then been soldered to the flange. To fit the dial to
the receiver entailed a lot of pushing and levering to get the
flange to fit in place and this had been done and the fixing
screw to secure the tuning condenser shaft had been tightened.
The result was slow motion tuning but somewhat lumpy with fast
mode very stiff. I decided that the slow motion dial must be
made to mate smoothly with the receiver otherwise we'd be back
to what it was previously. |
 |
This picture shows the
tuning condenser shaft. In fact what you see is a quarter inch
brass extension used for holding the pointer. This extension
is secured to the tuning condenser shaft.
The fibre block probably came
from the same source as the Muirhead dial. |
|
|
This is the G3PNV solution.
An excellent solution where
a metal extension is soldered to the original anchoring flange
extending it to mate with the fibre block. |
 |
|
 |
Here you see the problem.
The extension to the anchoring
flange is a few millimetres too far right and to make it align
with the slot means the flange has to be forced inwards. This
is possible but only by straining the mechanism which ends up
twisted to one side with the consequent rubbery lumpy feel and
very stiff direct drive. |
|
|
While I was pondering over how
to put this right I realised that all I needed to do was to unsolder
the extension, turn it upside down and solder it back into place.
I suspect G3PNV probably mistakenly
soldered his extension the wrong way up. It's easily done and
he hadn't noticed.
Here's the fix which moves the
extension about 5mm to the left so it engages with the groove
in the fibre block.
Refitting the dial was now a
case of just sliding it into place and tightening the screw to
hold the dial onto the tuning condenser. No pushing and shoving
and the dial works perfectly just like the one on my RF26. |
 |
|
|
Because nearly all amateur
communication is via SSB and I can hear strong amateur stations
on 7MHz it's essential I get the BFO working. When I first heard
noises from the set I thought I'd heard it but that I think was
IF instability. Looking at the underside of the BFO enclosure
I can see several disconnected wires and components and looking
inside the can it's possible that G3PNV had made changes to the
circuit. The R1155 BFO is built into a metal enclosure bolted
to the main chassis in such a way as to preclude a view of the
valve holder. I can see the thing has been removed before as
several screws are missing. The clues suggest that the BFO probably
gave trouble and I suspect G3PNV didn't get around to finishing
it.
R1155 documentation that I have
doesn't illustrate in sufficient detail for me to work out what's
going on. I looked on the Net for inspiration and immediately
found a BFO module for sale, complete with a set of colour pictures.
These pictures together with the circuit diagram and parts list
might help in getting the thing working. I've already replaced
the on/off switch. Could a faulty switch have been the original
problem? The fact it wasn't passing
HT through to the BFO circuit might explain the reason for the
disconnected parts and wiring. Maybe the solution is to check
the components fitted inside the enclosure and see if these are
in line with the original design then check the VR101 (=DL63)
anode and cathode voltages with the BFO switch turned on. I know
the valve should oscillate at half the IF or 280KHz and as the
circuit is extremely simple surely I won't have too much trouble.
An added complication is the
use of the VR101's double diodes which apparently are for deriving
audio. This may still be the case but I can see there are extra
valves present (eg a 6H6) that may be used instead.
Success... I measured the anode
of the VR101 as 270 volts and I also checked the cathode resistance
at pin 8 with the valve removed. This measured 5.3Kohm and I
found the second to back tag pin was 1Kohm to valve pin 8. Then
the penny dropped. Wired to the tag pin was a white wire going
to a front panel pot marked "RF Oscillator". I'd vaguely
thought that this pot was a fine tuning arrangement for the local
oscillator as I'd managed to do this in my ARR3 receiver for
fine tuning, but in fact it appears to be a method of altering
the magnitude of the BFO injection. The pot is 10Kohm and seems
a bit high for a cathode resistor so I turned it to zero and
the BFO started up. In fact the BFO is only working over a tiny
range of the pot so if this feature is desirable I'll need to
swap it for something like 1Kohm. I hooked up my oscilloscope
and found a perfect sinewave at the end of a disconnected coax
lead, but not at the expected frequency of 280KHz, instead it
was 560KHz. It seems G3PNV changed the circuitry to run at the
IF. This may have an advantage in resolving SSB as the BFO fine
tuner will have a greater range of adjustment.
Where should the loose coax
go? I stretched it out in the direction of the last IF stage
and found a small red capacitor connected to an otherwise unoccupied
tag close to the final IF transformer. It worked perfectly and
easily resolved 40m SSB signals. To fix the higher than optimum
pot I connected a 1Kohm resistor from the white wire to ground
essentially making the pot in parallel with this so the range
is now zero to 1Kohm on top of the fxed 1Kohm cathode resistor.
The BFO output has a range in amplitude of about 3:1 giving a
decent range of injection for SSB.
Below you can see pictures of
the BFO. |
 |
 |
 |
Above left is the BFO
enclosure with the nearside cover removed. That 2.2Mohm resistor
with an RFC just visible indicates the design has been changed.
The (new?) oscillator coil is mounted vertically next to the
trimmer.
Above, the underside connection
tags with a few still disconnected parts. The BFO valveholder
is completely inaccessible.
Left, the likely connection
point for the disconnected coax (the brown lead) fed from the
BFO tags. Later I changed this, as the BFO was too strong, to
a pot made from two 50pF capacitors. One grounded and the other
to that red capacitor with the coax fed to the common connection
of the pair. |
|
|
The next job is to figure
out the function of the toggle switch under the one for the BFO.
Pressing it down has an odd effect. It might merely be for shorting
the AVC line to ground resulting in excessive gain but in fact
it seems to reduce tuning bandwidth acting perhaps like a Q multiplier.
There's an added 6J5GT triode valve nearby. I unplugged this
and the audio vanished. There's also a VR53 (=EF39) adjacent
to the EF50 whose function is still to be determined. Perhaps
this is a Q multiplier?
I've swapped most of the old
condensers but there are still a few left which need attention
before I'm ready to proceed with final alignment. I proceeded
to swap the old can condensers and the gain slowly increased
but then I noticed some hum had been introduced. This seemed
to happen when I cut the lead to a condenser screwed to the back
of the coil enclosure and replaced it. By experiment (grounding
various points) I discovered the hum had been introduced into
the aerial circuitry. This problem is commonplace and is modulation
hum which occurs when the incoming RF gets mixed up with AC carried
in the metal chassis. Although the AC is miniscule so are incoming
signals and by trial and error I found that adding a couple of
high value resistors at strategic points in the aerial circuitry
eliminated the problem.
Although there's loads of overall
gain and reception is pretty good the background noise on highest
shortwave range is a lot less than the other ranges. I tapped
the aerial onto the mixer top cap and found a huge increase over
plugging into the aerial socket. The R1155 had a very complicated
RF switching arrangement due to the inclusion of DF elements
and this coupled with awkward acess in the coil box suggests
something isn't quite right. I noticed two loose wires in this
area so there may be a wiring fault. Another possibility is the
Range 1 aerial coil isn't tuning. Whilst looking for the fault
I noticed a new coil mounted below the wavechange switch. This
is in a blue colour and completely different to the others. I
also noted that the tuning cores in some of the other coils do
not have a slot in their end opposite the rear adjusting holes.
Adjustment is only possible from the very restricted space between
the back of the front panel and the front of the coil enclosure.
The blue coil, used for medium wave reception, is fitted to the
chassis so presumably is adjusted from the top? This coil must
explain the painting out of the dial. My guess is G3PNV didn't
get around to writing in the numbers on the scale for the modified
coverage. Because of the way the dial is fitted (remember it
had been incorrectly assembled making it virtually impossible
to remove!) it's tricky to access the scale and it was never
done.
As my HP signal generator had
developed a fault I used my Tiny SA in zero sweep mode to try
aligning the receiver. This task is nearly impossible do do properly
because the cores in the coils are not easy to get at. Not only
are they hard to reach from the back of the set where you're
supposed to tweak them, the cores have been replaced at some
time and the new ones only have a slot at the opposite (=wrong)
side. However the first pass produced the following. |
|
DIAL MARKING |
DIAL MARKING |
ACTUAL TUNING |
ACTUAL TUNING |
|
RANGE |
LOW |
HIGH |
LOW |
HIGH |
|
5 |
75KHz |
200KHz |
75KHz |
200KHz |
|
4 |
200KHz |
500KHz |
200KHz |
440KHz |
|
3 |
600KHz |
1500KHz |
710KHz |
1610KHz |
|
2 |
3MHz |
7.5MHz |
2.9MHz |
7.5MHz |
|
1 |
7.5MHz |
18MHz |
7.5MHz |
18MHz |
|
|
This isn't too bad. Firstly
Range 3 has been deliberately modified to cover the medium waveband
and the scale isn't marked. Range 4 is slightly puzzling but
may be wrong either due to a bad oscillator padder, or more likely
a bad core in coil. Not all the ranges track correctly resulting
in a difference from end to end in background noise level and
one or two coils in the aerial amplifier seem to peak. Again
the problem is likely to be bad cores. |
 |
|
I'm determined to figure out
why the receiver is a bit odd when it comes to alignment and
decided to partly rewire the first RF stage. For some reason
the AVC circuit is grounded and the penny soon dropped. The AVC
circuit is present but the Range 3 coil added by G3PNV has a
grounded return connection to its coil and aerial coupling coil.
This in turn grounds all the coils but it isn't important for
two reasons. Firstly AVC is now applied directly to the 6AK5
control grid and secondly I'm not sure the 6AK5 valve type likes
AVC because it's not a variable mu type like the old valve it
replaced.
The R1155 aerial circuitry is
extremely complex because of the DF features and anyone modifying
this area will discover it's not easy to understand. Some of
the wavechange wafers have selection switches and some have shorting
switches. The official diagrams don't show these idiosyncrasies
so modifications are fraught with difficulty.
I discovered that Range 5 has
no aerial coil explaining why its trimmer has no effect. I hunted
around and found a 10mH filter coil which will serve as an antenna
coil. Adding it brought up the VLF signals by quite a bit. Turning
to Range 1, I found the second RF stage tunes reasonably well
but the aerial coil seems nowhere near resonance. By connected
the signal generator directly to the 6AK5 grid brought up the
Range 1 gain by something like 30dB so I might dispense with
the 30pF aerial coupling condenser and wire the aerial socket
via something like 1nF (I did later use a different method). |
 |
 |
|
During alignment and dial
checking I initially used a few of my "professional"
signal generators but one started to give trouble and I eventually
settled on my Tiny SA shown here. As
with most modern electronic stuff many features are shrouded
in mystery but as I proceeded some really useful things started
to reveal themselves. I'll mention these later. Note the internal
battery seems to last for ages but it began to lose charge so
I plugged it into a battery pack as you can see above. |
|
|
|
The
Tiny SA has two different ways of operating. You can use
its waggly on/off switch or (much better) you can poke the touch-screen
with a pencil (my fingers are a bit too big for the tiny screen).
Initially you turn it on and set up the mode. In this case as
a signal generator. Poke "mode" then the various labels
to set the desired output port with AM and 1000Hz modulation,
then 18MHz, (no sweep is default but you can easily set this
to sweep the IF range centred on 560KHz). Default output is -7dBm
and you're presented with various amounts of frequency shift,
say +/- 10KHz and +/- 100KHz. Once you've aligned say 18MHz you
can step down in 100KHz steps whilst keeping the receiver in
tune to say 8MHz. That way you can avoid picking up an image
which is easy to do in the highest short wave range. In the set-up
above a loudspeaker is on the end of those red/black leads and
an audio wattmeter connected across the output transformer secondary.
I added some small fixed capacitors
across the trimmers and this helped compensate for damaged and
stuck cores, eventually getting alignment as good as it was ever
going to be. |
|
After a few hours I'd
come to the following final conclusions. The set was modified
very extensively but was an ongoing proposition, just like many
of my own projects. There are a few drawbacks. The Muirhead dial
isn't really man enough but works with some care ie. you mustn't
force it beyond the dial extremities. The S-meter works OK but
its two interactive controls need a lot of fiddling. The BFO
works (on 560KHz not half frequency) but needed some mods to
prevent overloading and I think G3PNV was aware of this but chose
to add a BFO output pot whose results are a bit weird. Does the
pot shift the frequency or attempt to change the level for SSB
reception? A BFO plus-minus frequency control is fitted on the
front panel to help deal with SSB, and there's a switch below
the BFO switch whose function is still a mystery. The AVC works
well***, keeping audio at a constant level, but overall receiver
gain is exceedingly high, helped by the 6AK5 RF stage and a very
high HT voltage. The RF gain pot cannot fully cope with a very
long wire bringing in strong broadcast signals. Strong signals
result in horrible oscillator pulling and, because the AVC is
so powerful, you can get strange S-meter effects. The audio output
stage is an EF50 and this leads to some bad distortion on strong
station reception and annoyingly its holder sometimes lets go
its grip on valve pins resulting in sudden deafness. A replacement
pair of IF transformers is fitted whose lower coils are inaccessible
(my guess is the original burnt out due to a "stock fault"
when a paper condenser failed).
*** bearing in mind a couple
of replacement valves are not variable mu.
A final check on the IF amplifier
was carried out. I didn't venture into a sweep test other than
just a subjective check with the Tiny SA, but it did reveal yet
another problem. Too much gain made the IF strip break into oscillation
when it was peaked which I managed to fix by inserting a 330
ohm resistor at a top cap of a convenient valve. Of course this
problem, as well as perhaps a few others may not have been apparent
to G3PNV.. why? Because I'd swapped nearly all the paper condensers
which had improved performance and as a side effect removed leakage
allowed HT to rise. In doing this in an AR88 a few years back
forced me to add a few resistors to emulate leakiness to bring
down excessive gain..
All the characteristics I noted
can be observed when using the receiver which I'm sure can be
dealt with by a listener after a few hours experience. There
are a few insurmountable technical things to mention. The top
range which covers 7.5 to 18MHz is slightly deaf because the
1st RF tuning coil has a jammed core. During final testing I
used my home-brew noise source.
This enabled me to check for flatness of audio across each range
and to compare the overall gain of the receiver, range to range.
It's a very rough and ready test but it is able to demonstrate
a couple of points. One is general alignment across a particular
range but more importantly it proves that alignment hasn't been
done on an image. The result of which is what I can only describe
as a noise-hole in a band.
So there it is. The receiver
is now operational. The design is unchanged from that decided
on by G3PNV except for a few minor things. The dial is still
silent or unsure on the frequency coverages of a couple of wavebands,
in particular the medium waveband which I puzzled over before
deciding to align at 1600KHz to around 700KHz. Was this the aim
of G3PNV? Anyway.. night time reception will be optimised as
more broadcasts are present at the higher end.
A few bits to be tidied up and
a few screws to be added and the set will be ready for collection....
I fitted the screening panel over the coil pack after re-checking
Range 1. Still unhappy about the lack of gain due to the badly
positiond core in the aerial coil I touched the aerial onto the
second RF stage and found the noise increased by around 10dB
(a large amount, not to be sneezed at). Fortunately there was
a simple bodge. I wired a 22pF capacitor from the Range 1 aerial
coil trimmer to the Range 1 RF amplifier trimmer. After removing
the extra 22pF I'd previously added to balance the RF trimmer
setting I was rewarded with my 10dB improvement. A real bodge
but now, when switching between Ranges 1 and 2, with my noise
source in place, the difference is much less marked. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|